Differences between CCPA and GDPR compliance

In this article, we delve into the critical compliance aspects of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and provide a CCPA vs GDPR analysis. Both legal frameworks aim to safeguard personal information and provide individuals with control over their data, but they do so in different ways and with different scopes of influence.

What is GDPR?

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is a set of laws that have been implemented in the European Union to protect the personal data of citizens within the EU. It applies to any company or organization that processes, stores or uses the personal data of any individual within an EU member state. The GDPR provides clear guidelines on what companies must do to ensure their systems and processes are compliant with GDPR regulations.

What is CCPA?

The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) is a law created by the state of California that has gone into effect as of January 1st, 2020. The law aims to give Californians stronger control over how businesses use their data and requires companies to disclose certain information when asked by consumers. Like GDPR, CCPA applies to businesses that collect, store or use the personal data of an individual within California.

CCPA vs GDPR: Compliance requirements

Understanding the compliance nuances between CCPA and GDPR is crucial for businesses operating under both regulations. While both regulations provide a framework for data protection, GDPR compliance is generally seen as more stringent due to its broader applicability and deeper requirements such as the need for privacy by design and default.

• GDPR focuses on protecting the personal information of EU citizens irrespective of where the data processor is located globally. This universal applicability makes GDPR a standard for any business operating in the EU or dealing with EU residents’ data.
• CCPA focuses more on transparency and giving control back to California’s consumers about how their personal information is used. CCPA compliance is a requirement for companies operating in California or dealing with the personal information of California residents.

Data Protection requirements: CCPA vs GDPR

Both CCPA and GDPR set robust frameworks for data protection, yet they possess distinct requirements that reflect their unique focuses and legislative contexts.

GDPR Data Protection requirements:

• Legal Basis for Processing: GDPR mandates that businesses must have a clear legal basis to process personal data. This could include explicit consent, necessity for contract fulfillment, legal obligations, protection of vital interests, public interest, or legitimate interests pursued by the data controller.
• Sensitive Personal Data: GDPR imposes additional protections for sensitive personal data, such as racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious beliefs, genetic data, biometric data, health information, and sexual orientation.
• Privacy by Design and Default: Organizations are required to implement data protection principles right from the design stage of any system, service, or process, and to ensure that personal data is processed with the highest privacy settings by default.
• Consent Requirements: GDPR emphasizes the need for clear, affirmative consent that is freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous as a basis for processing personal data, particularly in contexts where no other legal basis is applicable.

CCPA Data Protection requirements:

• Disclosure of Information Categories: The CCPA requires that businesses disclose the categories of personal information they collect and explain how this information is used and shared.
• Consumer Rights: CCPA enhances consumer rights by allowing Californians to know about, delete, and opt-out of the sale of their personal information. It places particular emphasis on the right to opt-out of the sale of personal information, which is narrower than GDPR’s broader right to object to processing.
• Scope of Personal Information: Under CCPA, personal information extends beyond just individual identifiers to include data related to households and devices, widening the scope of what businesses must manage.
• Access Rights: CCPA grants consumers broader access rights compared to GDPR, allowing them to request more detailed information about data usage and sharing practices.

Handling of data breaches and notification protocols

Both CCPA and GDPR mandate strict protocols in the event of a data breach, but their requirements differ in urgency and scope. GDPR requires that data breaches likely to result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals must be reported to the appropriate supervisory authority within 72 hours of the organization becoming aware of it. If the breach poses a high risk to individuals’ personal data, the organization must also inform those affected directly.

In contrast, the CCPA requires businesses to notify California residents of data breaches when unencrypted personal information is compromised. This notification must be expedient, without unreasonable delay, and should ideally occur within 48 hours of discovering the breach. The CCPA’s emphasis is more on the consumer’s right to know and seek damages, whereas GDPR focuses on both regulatory notification and individual communication, reflecting a more proactive stance on individual rights following a data breach.

Cross-border data transfers

The handling of cross-border data transfers under GDPR and CCPA also illustrates distinct regulatory philosophies. GDPR imposes strict guidelines on data transfer outside the EU, requiring that such transfers only occur to countries that provide an adequate level of data protection or through the implementation of appropriate safeguards such as standard contractual clauses or binding corporate rules. This framework ensures that the protection travels with the data, maintaining GDPR standards regardless of where the data is processed.

CCPA does not explicitly address cross-border data transfers but does require businesses to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices appropriate to the nature of the information to protect personal data. For companies operating both within California and globally, this often means that the more stringent international standards, like those posed by GDPR, will influence CCPA compliance strategies to ensure consistency across borders.

Consumer Rights to Data Portability and Deletion

The rights to data portability and deletion offered by GDPR and CCPA highlight significant aspects of individual empowerment in data management. Under GDPR, individuals have the right to data portability which allows them to obtain and reuse their personal data across different services. This means that they can request a copy of their data in a commonly used and machine-readable format, and they can also ask for this data to be transferred to another data controller, enhancing their control over how their information is used.

CCPA, while offering a broad scope of rights to access and delete personal information, does not specifically include a right to data portability in the same context as GDPR. However, the CCPA does require businesses to provide individuals with personal information collected in a readily usable format, which can indirectly support the transfer of data upon the consumer’s request. Both regulations emphasize the right of individuals to delete their personal data, with CCPA allowing consumers to request the deletion of their personal information held by businesses and by extension, any third parties to whom the business has transferred their data.

Regulatory oversight and enforcement mechanisms

The mechanisms for oversight and enforcement under CCPA and GDPR differ significantly, reflecting their respective legal and regulatory frameworks. GDPR is enforced by Data Protection Authorities (DPAs) across each EU member state, offering a coordinated approach to data protection with the power to conduct investigations and issue penalties. This robust mechanism ensures uniformity and seriousness in enforcement across Europe, with DPAs having significant authority to address non-compliance.

In contrast, the enforcement of CCPA is primarily the responsibility of the California Attorney General’s office, with no specific independent agency dedicated solely to data protection. While the CCPA provides for civil penalties imposed by the state and also includes provisions for private right of action by consumers in the event of data breaches, its enforcement model is generally considered less centralized than GDPR’s. This difference can lead to variations in how rigorously the law is enforced from one case to another, potentially affecting the uniformity of compliance requirements for businesses operating in California.

Penalties for non-compliance

The severity of penalties under both GDPR and CCPA underscores the serious commitment of these regulations to enforce data protection laws. Under GDPR, organizations may face substantial financial penalties of up to €20 million or 4% of their annual global turnover, depending on which is greater. This stringent fine structure highlights the regulation’s global reach and its insistence on strict adherence to privacy norms.

On the other hand, the CCPA sets penalties that can amount to up to $7,500 per violation. While these fines may appear less daunting in comparison to GDPR’s hefty penalties, they signify considerable financial risks for businesses that fail to comply, particularly those that handle large volumes of transactions or consumer data. Each non-compliance incident under CCPA can accumulate quickly into significant financial liabilities, emphasizing the importance of rigorous adherence to data protection standards prescribed by the CCPA.

Impact on business operations

The impact of CCPA and GDPR on business operations can be substantial, altering how companies collect, store, process, and manage data. GDPR requires businesses to conduct data protection impact assessments for processes that pose a high risk to personal data security, and to appoint a Data Protection Officer (DPO) in certain circumstances. This makes GDPR compliance not just about legal adherence but also about integrating data protection into business processes at all levels.

CCPA, while not mandating a DPO, requires businesses to implement reasonable security measures and systems to track consumer requests and their responses. This requirement means businesses must overhaul their data handling and customer interaction protocols to ensure timely and accurate compliance with consumer requests regarding their personal data.

Consumer trust and brand reputation

Adhering to CCPA and GDPR not only meets legal requirements but also boosts consumer trust and enhances brand reputation. In a digital age where data breaches and misuse of personal information are frequent, compliance with these regulations demonstrates a commitment to data security and respect for consumer privacy. GDPR, with its stringent penalties and broad scope, sends a strong message about the importance of data protection, helping businesses build trust with a global audience. Similarly, CCPA empowers Californians by reinforcing their rights over personal data, thereby encouraging loyalty among consumers who value privacy.

Businesses that transparently communicate their compliance with these regulations often enjoy enhanced customer confidence and competitive advantage. This trust is crucial for maintaining customer base and attracting new clients in an increasingly privacy-conscious market.

Global reach and extraterritorial application

One of the most notable aspects of GDPR is its extraterritorial application. GDPR affects any business that processes the data of EU citizens, regardless of whether the company is based in the EU. This global reach requires companies around the world to comply with its regulations if they wish to operate in or cater to the European market. This broad application contrasts with the CCPA, which specifically targets businesses that operate in California or handle the personal data of California residents.

However, with the trend towards stricter data protection laws globally, understanding and implementing GDPR standards can provide a robust framework for businesses preparing for future regulations in other regions. Meanwhile, CCPA sets a precedent for other US states considering similar laws, making compliance a strategic move for future-proofing a business against upcoming state-level regulations.

Why Cassie is the best compliance solution for both CCPA and GDPR

We have been helping global businesses achieve compliance for many years. We are truly unmatched when it comes to achieving compliance in ways that also help businesses deliver against commercial objectives.

Choose Cassie: Compliance without compromise

Most Consent and Preference Management Platform (CMP) providers offer templated solutions for legislation compliance: it may be true that you’ll become ‘compliant’ quickly, however, you will have to fit your business rules and workflow around the vendor’s template, legal interpretations and assumptions.

With Cassie, compliance is not an either/or scenario between meeting legal standards and pursuing business growth. Our solutions are crafted to integrate seamlessly into your business processes, enhancing data management practices while boosting consumer trust and revenue.

By choosing Cassie, you’re investing in a compliance partner that supports your business’s expansion and adapts to its changing needs. These improvements aim to enhance clarity, add persuasive elements, and more effectively highlight the benefits of choosing Cassie as a compliance solution.